US pioneers encounter obstacles

NEW YORK: In more than one sense, Brian Rice and Jason Kelliher are pioneers. They were among the first same-sex partners in the United States to marry legally last year in barrier-breaking Massachusetts and now are among the few such couples to forgo their much-prized rights by moving to another state.

Their new home, Connecticut, is among the most liberal on the issue; its legislature has approved civil unions that extend marriage-like rights to gay couples. But that option doesn't tempt Rice and Kelliher.

"We've already reached the pinnacle of what a couple can hope for a marriage license," said Rice, a lawyer. "Civil union is a second-class citizenship. We don't want to take a step backward."

Yet Rice and Kelliher know that if they venture to any other state except back to Massachusetts their status wouldn't improve. While a few states have recognized same-sex couples, many more are strengthening bans on gay marriage. Conservatives in some places including Michigan and Ohio are now taking aim at existing domestic-partner benefit policies.

"There are lots of families in states where it's harder to be a strong family, where the state does everything it can to weaken you," said David Buckel, an attorney for gay rights group Lambda Legal. "It's challenging, it's discouraging, at some points it's enraging."

Rice, 27, and Kelliher, 29, moved from Boston in August 2004 because of a job offer for Rice in Stamford, Connecticut. Kelliher now qualifies for domestic-partner health benefits from Rice's law firm.

They initially hoped Connecticut would recognize their marriage, but the state decided otherwise. They can't file joint state tax returns, as they could have in Massachusetts, and worry that they need to execute a will because Connecticut wouldn't consider the survivor a spouse in the event one of them died.

"There are very few attorneys who specialize in these issues, and the law is very unsettled," Rice said. "If you're moving from state to state, or travelling, protections you had in one state may not be available in another."

Despite the uncertainties, the couple sense they are better off in New England than in the dozens of other states that have explicitly outlawed gay marriage. Many have enshrined such bans in their constitutions, while several also forbid civil unions.

Source: China Daily